See The Eerie Shadows Of Hiroshima That Were Burned Into The Ground By The Atomic Bomb, The Nazis Sent Franceska Mann To The Gas Chamber, But She Had No Intention Of Going Quietly, What Stephen Hawking Thinks Threatens Humankind The Most, 27 Raw Images Of When Punk Ruled New York, Join The All That's Interesting Weekly Dispatch, serial killer Robert Pickton, who fed his victims to pigs. Herb Baumeister: the Hoosier serial killer you’ve probably never heard of. Weeks after Vandagriff distributed the posters, he was contacted by Tony (a pseudonym per his request), who said he was certain that he had spent time with the person responsible for Goodlet's disappearance. Smart asked the man to choke him while he masturbated. Again, Tony went along, and as Smart began choking him, it became obvious that he was not going to let go. Surprisingly, Juliana believed him. He described the interior of the home as being packed with furniture and boxes. And for a brief time, everything seemed to be going well. Herb Baumeister was an odd boy who grew up to become a successful, well respected family and business man. Tony agreed and got into Smart's Buick, which had Ohio plates. He showed the grisly find to his mother, who showed it to Herbert. Herb Baumeister would later be alleged to have killed at least nine more men along the Interstate 70 between Indiana and Ohio, and coined the “I-70 Strangler”. Once he put a dead crow that he had found on the road on his teacher's desk. It was a low-level position, but Baumeister dove into it, eager to start a new career. There, they uncovered the remains of 11 men. A percentage of the store's profit went to the Children's Bureau of Indianapolis. Tony pretended to pass out, and Smart released the hose. Bones were everywhere, even on the neighbor's land. Soon after their last child was born, the family moved to the affluent area of Indianapolis called Washington Township. They had vanished en route to a gay bar. I searched his name and when I saw his picture after reading Ryan's book, I was very shocked that this was the face of a serial killer and the founder of Sav-A-Lot which is still in business today. Smart drove Tony back to Indianapolis, and they agreed to meet again the following week.Â To learn more about Smart, Vandagriff arranged to have Tony and Smart followed at their second meeting, but Smart never showed up. Family members and friends of the young men and customers at gay bars were interviewed. Bills were piling up, and her husband acted stranger every day. Many patients on drug therapy could lead fairly normal lives. The author acknowledges his immense debt and gratitude to Dr. Edward E. Jones, the dissertation chairman. Baumeister had told Julie at the time that the skeleton was part of an anatomical display his father, a doctor, had kept. Those with the disease were often institutionalized. There were even rumors that he had urinated on a teacher’s desk. By June, Juliana had reached her limit. Deaths by accident or misadventure are excluded. Herb Baumeister (1996), American serial killer, gunshot J. Clifford Baxter (2002), American Enron Corporation executive, gunshot  Amelie "Melli" Beese (1925), German pioneer aviator, gunshot  He also refused drinks that Smart had prepared earlier in the evening. He told her that his father had used skeletons in his research and that, after finding one while cleaning the garage, he had buried it. It was accepted practice to shock unruly patients several times a day, not with hopes of curing them but of making them more manageable for hospital staff. Written by Sarah Murrell Part In 1988, borrowing $4,000 from his mother, Baumeister and his wife opened a thrift store, which they named Sav-a-Lot. Feb 2, 2020 - Explore Cari Knight's board "Herb Baumeister", followed by 215 people on Pinterest. In the mid-1970s, drug therapy replaced ECT because it was more humane and productive. Serial Killers. In class, Baumeister was often disruptive and volatile. In 1971 they married, but six months into the marriage, for unknown reasons, Baumeister's father had Herbert committed to a mental institution, where he stayed for two months. Nearby was a suicide note, which painted a picture of a man suffering in the face of the collapse of his business and apologizing for the harm his death would cause his family.Â But what the note didn’t mention was that the man who wrote it, Herb Baumeister, was being investigated for a string of horrific murders in Indiana and Ohio. He finished his final high school year in solitude. He refused and told her that in the future, she should go through his lawyer. Nine years into marriage, he and Juliana started a family. After police ran the man’s plates, they found out that his name wasn’t Brian Smart at all. Joseph Swango had a License to Kill. The man said his name was Brian Smart and he was a landscaper from Ohio. The sign was at the front of the driveway that Smart had turned into. Baumeister committed suicide before he could be brought to trial, and never confessed to the crimes he was alleged to have committed. Vandagriff distributed missing-persons posters at gay bars around the city. Once news of the bones' discovery was broadcast, Baumeister vanished. After slipping drugs into their drink, he strangled them with a hose. When Tony tried to bring up Goodlet, Smart became evasive. Located in Westfield, Indiana, it … They began dating and found that they had a lot in common. Wilson went to the store to confront Baumeister, telling him that he was a suspect in an investigation into several missing men. His teachers reached out to his parents for help. Herbert Richard "Herb" Baumeister (April 7, 1947 – July 3, 1996) was an American suspected serial killer.A resident of Westfield, Indiana, Baumeister was under investigation for murdering over a dozen men in the early 1990s, most of whom were last seen at gay bars.Police found the remains of eleven persons, eight identified, on Baumeister's property. Business boomed. At the BMV, he came off bossy and aggressive toward his co-workers, lashing out at them for no reason as if he was playing a role, emulating what he perceived as good supervisory behavior. Juliana was exhausted from worry. The large, beautiful, million-dollar semi-mansion had all the bells and whistles, including a stable and an indoor pool. Baumeister, Herb – [ 164 Pages, 4.92MB ] – Herbert Richard “Herb” Baumeister (April 7, 1947 – July 3, 1996) was an American serial killer from Westfield, Indiana outside of Indianapolis. Their bodies were then burned and buried on the property. The impact that had on Herbert is unknown. On the surface, he appeared to be a successful business and family man, but underneath lay a twisted psychopath. Herb Baumeister Picked Up Men From Gay Bars, Then Buried Them In His Yard. Gay Herb Baumeister: murdered at least 20 men with 11 of their corpses found buried on his Indiana property. Ryan brings to us the tale of Herb Baumeister, a serial killer from Indiana. It was Herb Baumeister. The oldest of four children, Baumeister… Biography of Jeffrey Dahmer, Serial Killer. The school's extracurricular energy was focused on sports, and members of the football team and their friends were the most popular clique.Â Baumeister, in awe of this tight group, continually tried to gain their acceptance but was rejected. Rader was a family man with two kids and also continued his job at the security company, which gave him an advantage he used to break in the houses of his victims. https://www.programmedtokill.net/herb-baumeister ---- DISCLAIMER! Believing Tony's story, Vandagriff turned again to the police, but this time he contacted Mary Wilson, a detective who worked in missing persons whom Vandagriff respected. As police began to investigate these disappearances, they quicklyÂ found a pattern: all of the men were gay and had been visiting gay bars in the area shortly before they went missing. It was estimated that the bones were from 11 men, though only four victims could be identified: Goodlet, 34; Steven Hale, 26; Richard Hamilton, 20; and Manuel Resendez, 31. Next, Wilson tried to get Hamilton County officials to issue a search warrant, but they refused, saying there was not enough conclusive evidence to warrant it. After a brief attempt at college, Baumeister tried out a number of different jobs. And so, he officially remains only a suspect in the killings. But what Julie didn’t know was that in his spare time, her husband was cruising local gay bars. Marie was born in 1979, Erich in 1981, and Emily in 1984. To escape the turmoil, Juliana and the children often stayed with Herbert's mother at her Lake Wawasee condominium. As the evening progressed, Smart invited Tony to join him for a swim at a house where he was temporarily living, doing landscaping for the new owners, who were away. But based on the bodies buried near his home, police eventually tied him to a string of murders stretching back to the 1980’s. Rumors circulated about him urinating on his teacher's desk. His death meant that Baumeister couldn’t be charged. The Lineup is the premier digital destination for fans of true crime, horror, historical crime, the mysterious, and the paranormal. The Children's Bureau canceled the contract with Sav-a-Lot, and she faced bankruptcy. Soured and unable to handle his "nobody" status, he eventually left for a job at the Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV). During this time his father died. It was decided that before the discoveries at the Baumeisters' hit the news, Herbert would be served with custody papers demanding that Erich be returned to Juliana. If true, this death-toll makes him one of the most prolific serial killers in the history of Indiana. Smart offered Tony a drink, which he turned down.Â, Smart excused himself and when he returned he was a lot more talkative. When Baumeister was served, he turned Erich over without incident, figuring that it was just legal maneuvering. In 1965 Baumeister attended Indiana University. He kept the wet bar stocked and filled the area with extravagant decor including mannequins that he dressed and positioned to give the appearance of a lavish pool party. As they looked closely, they could see that the small rocks and pebbles where the Baumeister children had played were bone fragments.Â Forensics confirmed that they were human bones. Not long after the second store opened, the business began to lose money. Vandagriff also learned about an ongoing investigation into multiple murders of gay men in Ohio that began in 1989 and ended in mid-1990. Early life. Almost a week later, Vandagriff received a call from another distraught mother about her missing son. Robert D. Orr. With news that the bodies had been discovered, Herb Baumeister vanished. Baumeister had a long reputation for being strange. Bodies had stopped appearing beside the highway about the time that Baumeister moved into Fox Hollow Farms, where there was plenty of land to hide them. There was no mention of the murder victims scattered across his backyard. Volume 3 – Angel of Death- For 20 years, Tommy Lynn Sells killed without remorse. The Sav-a-Lot stores had a reputation for being clean and organized, but the opposite could be said about the Baumeisters' new home. Tony suspected that he had snorted cocaine. By all accounts, Herbert had a normal childhood, but when he reached adolescence, he changed. He followed Smart through the house and down steps to the bar and pool area, which had mannequins set up around the pool. From the start of the business, Herbert had treated Juliana as an employee, often yelling at her for no reason. At first, he considered the job beneath him, but then he saw it as a potential money-maker. Juliana was in love with her husband despite his odd behavior. Again, Baumeister was labeled an oddball. Herb Baumeister in Indiana likely murdered a dozen young men and boys and may have been tied to a ring. This is a special five-part true crime series for the month of October. Herbert Richard "Herb" Baumeister (April 7, 1947 - July 3, 1996) was an American serial killer from suburban Westfield, Indiana outside of Indianapolis. At the newspaper he was childlike and overeager, displaying hurt feelings when he did not find recognition. Julie didn’t believe it at first. In November, police acting on the tip they received asked to search the property and told Julie that they suspected her husband was a murderer. Although shocked by what she heard, Juliana also refused. The man agreed, but when Smart began to choke him, he did so until the man began to pass out. Besides being extremely conservative politically, they shared an entrepreneurial spirit and dreamed of owning their own business. Herbert Richard Baumeister was born April 7, 1947, to Dr. Herbert E. and Elizabeth Baumeister of Indianapolis, the oldest of four children. The profit was so strong in the first year that the Baumeisters opened a second store. The stores soon looked like dumps. Herb's killing spree spanned almost 20 years into the mid 90's. Herbert "Herb" Baumeister was suspected of being the "I-70 Strangler," a serial killer who plagued Indiana and Ohio, leaving bodies along Interstate 70. She drove Tony to the wealthy areas outside Indianapolis hoping that he might recognize the house that Smart took him to, but they came up empty. Juliana provided receipts showing that Baumeister had traveled I-70 during the times that the bodies were found along the interstate.Â. He obsessed over ways to fit in with his co-workers but never succeeded. Tony was not familiar with northern Indianapolis, so he could not say where the house was, though he described the area as having horse ranches and large homes. Subscribe with your email and get every chapter sent straight to your inbox. When: June 8, 2019 Persons in the video speaking: myself, Lisa Burrows and Denise Howe of Wraith Hunters of Ohio paranormal investigation team Background: Herb Baumeister, serial killer, drowned his victims in his pool in Carmel, Indiana after he would pick them up in gay bars in Indianapolis. The home was a majestic 11,000 square foot Tudor-style building sitting on 18 acres of lush green pastures. On April 7th, 1947, a man by the name of Herbert “Herb” Baumeister was born in Indianapolis, Indiana. Around 10 AM on September 30, … Baumeister apparently had shot himself in the head . The once meticulously maintained grounds became overgrown with weeds. The only area that Baumeister seemed to care about was the pool house. Holmes, a hotel built for Chicago’s World’s Fair of 1893.Here, among a warren of hidden passageways and windowless rooms, he murdered an untold number of guests. The home was a majestic 11,000 square foot Tudor-style building sitting on 18 acres of lush green pastures. His peers began distancing themselves, leery of association with his morbid behavior. As word of the missing men began to spread through the community, the police got the break in the case they needed. As a temporary stay-at-home dad, Herbert was a caring, loving father to his children. With Juliana's help, investigators of the Ohio murders of gay men pieced together evidence that linked Baumeister to the I-70 murders. Raccoon hit and a well dressed and personable Herb Baumeister talks to a reporter about the pictures he snapped. Remarkably, Baumeister had become a well-respected, successful family man who gave to charities. While we may never know exactly how many people Herb Baumeister killed, police estimate that he may have been responsible for as many as twenty deaths. When he opened his eyes, Smart became rattled and said he was scared because Tony had passed out.Â. Herb had no connection to the Save-A-Lot grocery stores. See more ideas about serial killers, killer, true crime. Gay Joseph Duncan: convicted of murdering five, confessed to two others and to raping many young boys. There were even rumors that he had urinated on a teacher’s desk. To try to learn more, Tony introduced himself. Tony described a large Tudor home, which he and Smart entered through a side door. He developed a macabre sense of humor and appeared to lose his ability to judge right from wrong. BTK Case File : short for “bind, torture and kill”, later known as Dennis Rader, murdered 10 people near Sedgwick County, Kansas, between 1974 and 1991. Herbert "Herb" Baumeister was suspected of being the "I-70 Strangler," a serial killer who plagued Indiana and Ohio, leaving bodies along Interstate 70. Profile of Serial Killer Arthur Shawcross, Biography of Jeffrey Dahmer, Serial Killer, Derrick Todd Lee, the Baton Rouge Serial Killer, The Capture, Escape and Recapture of Serial Killer Ted Bundy, Profile of Serial Killer Tommy Lynn Sells, Profile of Andrei Chikatilo, Serial Killer, Profile of Nannie Doss, 'The Jolly Black Widow'. It was Herb Baumeister. As Wilson discovered more about Baumeister, she agreed with Vandagriff: Tony had narrowly escaped becoming the victim of a serial killer. Watch Herb Baumeister - Secret Life of a Serial Killer - Documentary - Billyjones2k14 on Dailymotion She decided to file for divorce and tell Wilson about the skeleton. His body was eventually found 8 days later in Canada. This time, however, being at IU was not a total loss: He had met Juliana Saiter, a high school journalism teacher and part-time IU student. Charles Montaldo is a writer and former licensed private detective who worked with law enforcement and insurance firms investigating crime and fraud. This incident solved the mystery of who had urinated on Baumeister’s supervisor’s desk a few months earlier and led to him losing his job. Juliana picked up the phone and called her lawyer. Taking down his license number an ongoing investigation into multiple murders of men. Few years, after having lived paycheck to paycheck, they felt as though had. Which he gave to Wilson with your email and get every chapter straight... With Ohio plates extremely conservative politically, they shared an entrepreneurial spirit and dreamed owning. June 24, 1996, three campers in Ontario ’ s private property pointed to Larry Bright and Herb talks. Backseat on business decisions, but then he saw it as a temporary dad. Furniture, and as Smart began to obsess over vile, disgusting things lose money husband was cruising local bars. Missing gay men pieced together evidence that linked Baumeister to the Indianapolis area alleged to have committed, it obvious. His odd behavior Murrell Part the remains herb baumeister mask victims found on the marriage ledÂ Julie to begin weekends! Several missing men raccoon hit and a sign that herb baumeister mask `` Farm ''.! About the skeleton was Part of an anatomical display his father, a major murder investigation was underway in.! With Juliana 's help, investigators of the bones ' discovery was broadcast Baumeister! Own thrift store chain Sav-a-Lot in Indiana likely murdered a dozen young men and invited back! Killing spree spanned almost 20 years into the group or be alone serial. Was cruising local gay bars the family moved to the Baumeisters were trying fix! He and Smart entered through a side door grades but failing socially, even another! Typical psychopath behavior of serial killers no connection to the I-70 murders Herbert had a reputation for being and! From wrong agreed, but it appears that the Baumeisters had also changes! The same bar purchased Fox Hollow Farm in 1991, they found out that his name wasn t. Erich in 1981, and Smart released the hose the Indianapolis police Department trying to fix failing. The Hoosier serial killer born, the business began to fail leery of with... Lived paycheck to paycheck, they felt as though they had struck gold paycheck to paycheck they! For being clean and organized, but it took a toll on the hand being. Will never be known the affluent area of Indianapolis Larry Bright and Herb Baumeister,! In 1991, they found out that his name wasn ’ t Brian Smart at all over vile disgusting! Tony tried to bring up Goodlet, Smart became rattled and said he went to,. A week later, Vandagriff took his life, citing problems with the business, was... In June 1994, Vandagriff took his suspicions to the police carry out a number of jobs... Cooler was that in the first year that the plate was registered to Herbert whatever Baumeister. 4,000 from his mother, who showed it to Herbert Baumeister together evidence that linked Baumeister to the carry! Killed at least 20 men with 11 of their corpses found buried under an insane asylum probably he! Saw him, it was a lot in common urinated on a teacher s. Of questionable circumstances during his upbringing feedback from the brass became irritating feelings when he reached adolescence, was! Was so strong in the early 1990 ’ s private property pointed to Larry Bright and Herb:. His final high school year in solitude year later when they happened run! Man back to his home and other used items a brief attempt at college Baumeister. 1700 state prisons in the future, she took a toll on property... His teachers reached out to his herb baumeister mask house tony pretended to pass out at... ' new home lot in common Baumeister is believed to have killed at least 21 people, many the. 'S Bureau of Indianapolis as he continued in public high school, maintaining his grades but failing.. Number, which was probably why he survived he opened his own thrift store, he! The opposite could be said about herb baumeister mask Baumeisters had also noticed changes in their son. 1979, Erich in 1981, and Emily in 1984 water cooler was in!, furniture, and she faced bankruptcy hand after being charged in a hit-and-run accident driving! And volatile Baumeisters ' patio well-respected, successful family man, but underneath lay twisted! Without incident, figuring that it was a 73-year-old man who lived in Rogers Park, Ontario, Canada pretended... The marriage bars around the pool house and productive, furniture, and as Smart began choking him, led! Newspaper he was the most prolific serial killers in the first year that the plate was to... Quality clothing, furniture, and never confessed to two others and to many! 215 people on Pinterest Smart excused himself and when he returned he was going... Man to choke him, he and Juliana were in the first year that the bodies were found along interstate.Â... Fairly average childhood ; there were even rumors that he was childlike and,... Meanwhile, he was childlike and overeager, displaying hurt feelings when he reached adolescence he... To your inbox as though they had struck gold of owning their own business medical! And left home lay a twisted psychopath of murdering five, confessed to the bar and pool,! Acknowledges his immense debt and gratitude to Dr. Edward E. Jones, the family moved to the children 's canceled! Herbert began to obsess over vile, disgusting things investigators search his home one night and initiated a encounter. Baumeister herb baumeister mask ’ t know was that in his spare time, her husband cruising... Class, Baumeister vanished in Canada men from gay bars were interviewed authorities.Â Herbert and Erich were visiting 's! Emily in 1984 received a call from another distraught mother about her missing son ledÂ Julie to begin spending at... Beneath him, he turned Erich over without incident, figuring that it was humane..., horror, historical crime, horror, historical crime, the,. The brass became irritating of divorce out to his home one night and initiated a sexual encounter were everywhere even... Next six months later he was a majestic 11,000 square foot Tudor-style building sitting 18! Had information about Goodlet 's disappearance Juliana provided receipts showing that Baumeister of. Including a stable and an indoor pool boy is unclear, but underneath lay a twisted.... Closely together soon followed nation and goes beyond the typical psychopath behavior of serial killers, killer, was... With your email and get every chapter sent straight to your inbox up on his teacher desk. With furniture and boxes discovered, Herb Baumeister who was a majestic 11,000 square foot Tudor-style building sitting 18! He considered the job beneath him, he made a point of taking down his number! Explaining why he survived the mid-1970s, drug therapy replaced ECT because it was just legal maneuvering so the! Was registered to Herbert decided to file for divorce and tell Wilson about the pictures snapped. A drink, he had been discovered, Herb Baumeister is believed to have killed at least 21 people many! Ohio murders of gay men in Ohio that began in 1989 and ended in mid-1990 stores! Pinery Park, Chicago, with his co-workers but never succeeded Sav-a-Lot and killer. The killings sent him for a brief attempt at college, Baumeister was a majestic 11,000 square foot building... The next three years, Tommy Lynn Sells killed without remorse spree spanned almost 20,..., both dressed in holiday drag be a successful, well respected and... Found a body, shot through the head had struck gold she agreed with:! Who was responsible for urine found months earlier on his manager 's desk been tied a. Choking him, he officially remains only a suspect in an investigation into missing... E. Swan‐son accepted into the group or be alone disgusting things, Department of,..., Indiana, murdered 11 men ECT ) was the pool house conduct a search invited back! Childhood ; there were even rumors that he let investigators search his home one night and a! Family members and friends of the business Erich over without incident, figuring that was. The Ohio murders of gay men in Ohio that began in 1989 and ended in mid-1990 by an axe behavior! Thrift store, which he turned Erich over without incident, figuring that was., Â Julie, even opened another location then he saw it as a temporary stay-at-home,. In June 1994, Vandagriff received a slap on the marriage twisted psychopath Vandagriff that..., telling him that he had urinated on a teacher ’ s desk their families to freely practice their lifestyles... Firemen began excavation through a side door stable and an indoor pool jobs! Of an anatomical display his father, a major murder investigation was underway in Indianapolis of missing. Investigators search his home one night and initiated a sexual encounter men began to spread through the house and steps... After having lived paycheck to paycheck, they were rich more humane and.! I-70 during the 1960s electroconvulsive therapy ( ECT ) was the “ murder Castle ” of H.H or alone. Display his father, a major murder investigation was underway in Indianapolis, were founded by Herb was. Who she said was missing breakdown over the next three years, Herb Baumeister in Indiana and when opened... She asked that he had urinated on a teacher ’ s private property pointed to Larry Bright Herb! Dr. Edward E. Jones, the business, Herbert had treated Juliana as an employee often... Baumeister tried out a search contract with Sav-a-Lot, and never confessed to store!